An inspection of one Adelaide emergency department found that some patients had been in the ED for more than 36 hours, with doctors saying ‘we are at our wit’s end’.
Conditions at a northern Adelaide hospital emergency department are “demoralising” and “depressing”, a new report has revealed, with staff reporting that the ED has been working at 100-200% over capacity for several months, leaving doctors overwhelmed and “empty”.
The report by the SA Salaried Medical Officers Association (SASMOA) said the 34-bed Modbury Hospital ED had 22 patients waiting for a bed during an inspection by the union on 30 September, and patients were waiting three to four hours to receive care.
But SASMOA is calling for a review of WorkSafe South Australia’s internal processes after the regulator inspected the emergency department three weeks later and found no health and safety issues.
The union warned that SafeWork SA’s lack of transparency and findings after inspecting the ED “pose a serious risk to worker’s health and safety and serious threat more broadly to the public”.
SASMOA’s report said patients were waiting for results in cubicles without walls or were given “corridor care”, and could be waiting for more than three days, resulting in dissatisfied patients, frustrated family members and an increase in code blacks.
“We are at our wit’s end,” one doctor was quoted as saying in the report.
“In the years I have been here this is the worst I have ever seen including the total number of patients waiting for a hospital bed in our ED.”
Doctors reported compassion fatigue, burnout and low morale in the ED, saying that absenteeism was high and “sick leave has just spiralled”.
Seven patients had been in the ED for more than 24 hours, and four had been there for longer than 36 hours, leading to “significant crankiness from patient[s] and their families”, the report said.
“One doctor we interviewed said that ‘this is just a daily shit show’,” the report said.
Doctors described feeling empty and demoralised caring for long-stay patients in the ED with nowhere for them to go.
“The nurses cop it and we cop it,” doctors said.
One doctor said: “I would be angry as well, hidden behind curtains, sleep deprived, I wouldn’t do it to my dog.”
“We are maxed out and it has been for months not just winter,” another doctor said.
Staff looked forward to receiving left-over donuts from a local bakery in times of “overwhelm and stress”, the report said.
SASMOA chief industrial officer Bernadette Mulholland submitted a report to WorkSafe SA claiming work health and safety legislation was contravened during an inspection of the emergency department on 30 September.
Ms Mulholland said SASMOA had been asked to attend the site on 30 September by doctors because of “the significant impact consistent overcrowding had on frontline health workers including on morale, health and wellbeing and ongoing risks to patients in the emergency department”.
Ms Mulholland said SASMOA was disappointed – considering the immediate risks identified in the report – that WorkSafe SA had entered the workplace to follow up the report around three weeks later on 19 October.
“We were advised by SafeWork SA following their entry that they could find no health and safety issues and their email notifying SASMOA of this fact was to remain confidential and not be released,” Ms Mulholland said.
“When SASMOA questioned the breadth of the inspection including what doctors SafeWork SA spoke to at the site investigation; the issues contained in the report and the evidence to support the findings of SafeWork SA, SASMOA was advised by the regulator that the evidence to support the findings would not be provided.”
Related
Ms Mulholland said WorkSafe SA warned the union that if they publicly shared the regulator’s emails, they could be penalised up to $50,000.
“It is SASMOA’s view SafeWork SA lack of transparency around these investigations and findings poses a serious risk to worker’s health and safety and serious threat more broadly to the public and we urge the state government to review the regulator’s secretive processes.”
Ms Mulholland questioned who WorkSafe SA was protecting.
“Certainly in our view, they are not protecting workers or vulnerable patients in our public hospitals”.
A SafeWork SA spokesperson confirmed that an inspector had attended Modbury Hospital on 19 October to meet with Northern Adelaide Local Health Network (NALHN) staff about the allegations raised in the report, which had been lodged with SafeWork SA on 12 October.
“No issues were identified warranting further regulatory action and SafeWork SA has finalised its involvement in the matter,” the spokesperson said.
Northern Adelaide Local Health Network CEO Karen Puvogel said the health and wellbeing of staff and patients was a high priority and any concerns were taken seriously.
Ms Puvogel said SafeWork SA visited Modbury Hospital on Monday last week and met with staff to review the issues raised by SASMOA.
“Following those enquiries, SafeWork SA has not found any issues warranting further regulatory action and has finalised its involvement in the matter.
“NALHN understands the impact our busy system has on staff, which is compounded by the record numbers of patients in our hospitals awaiting an aged care bed, and is looking at further ways to improve how we support our workforce.”
Ms Puvogel said NALHN was currently exploring options with private providers to increase bed capacity at both the Lyell McEwin and Modbury hospitals to alleviate pressure on the emergency departments. Thirty new beds had been opened at Burnside and Lyell McEwin hospitals in recent weeks to help manage demand, she said.
South Australian minister for health and wellbeing Blair Boyer said he took the wellbeing of doctors, nurses and other hospital staff extremely seriously.
“We acknowledge the pressures they have been facing amid unprecedented demand across our northern hospitals, due to the aged care crisis caused by a lack of federal residential aged care beds,” he said.
“While SafeWork SA did not identify workplace safety contraventions, the report highlights what we already know: northern hospitals are experiencing extraordinary demand driven by a growing population, increasingly complex patient needs and significant challenges discharging older patients awaiting aged care placements.
“The report itself notes that the 20 beds opened for older patients at Lyell McEwin Hospital in September were filled within a week, underscoring the impact of the aged care crisis.”
Mr Boyer said the state government had opened more than 200 additional beds in the suburbs and had secured an additional 10 beds at Burnside Hospital.
“We are progressing negotiations for a further eight care-awaiting-placement beds to support capacity in the north. We have also opened the 20-bed OASIS Unit and are expanding alternative care pathways to help reduce pressure on emergency departments.”
Rising acuity and complexity overwhelms emergency department
The report revealed the concerns of several staff members, describing challenges in discharging elderly patients who did not have social supports or were waiting for a residential care facility placement.
“Two doctors reported that in their many years of practice they haven’t seen the ED in this condition and are concerned that it will only get worse.”
Those doctors said they had to wait for ambulances for patients who had been dropped off by ambulance at the Modbury ED because it had shorter waiting times than the nearby Lyell McEwin Hospital ED.
“The patient requires surgical services we do not have, so the ambulance is called to take the patient from Modbury Hospital to the LMH.
“The different professions are cross with each other when it is none of our fault we simply don’t have the capacity or the patient is at the wrong hospital.”
Doctors also reported that there had been a room in the ED for taking blood and assessing patients, but that room had been “taken away without consultation” and was being used for other purposes.
“Doctors reported that the capacity of the ED is not enough to meet the changes in acuity and complex nature of presentations, this has resulted in longer ED stays,” the report said.
“Doctors reported that general practitioners are referring patients to the ED, and the increase in health care has contributed to increase in ED presentations.”
One doctor said: “I don’t understand why we can rack and stack very infectious patients with other patients in the waiting room and the government thinks this is safe and think they can damage our morale and undermine a desire to be a good doctor.”



