$2.23 billion, three coffees, three beers: Enrico Coiera vs Claude

4 minute read


Claude thinks it’s okay to steal the IP of one of our country’s healthcare AI national treasures and pay him in flat whites.


Professor Enrico Coiera has finally been paid for teaching Claude health informatics. Sort of.

The professor, who runs the Centre for Health Informatics at Macquarie University, and who is probably Australia’s foremost expert on AI in healthcare, found his textbook caught up in Bartz v Anthropic, a US class action over pirated books used to train Claude.

Professor Coiera woke up recently to the exciting news that the case had settled in the plaintiffs’ favour for AUD$2.23 billion. Three editions of Guide to Health Informatics, many years and, by his account, a lot of lost sleep went into this work.

The bad news: when that AUD$2.23 billion gets distributed the headline rate is about AUD$4500 per stolen book.

Professor Coiera has done the maths on LinkedIn, and the number shrinks at every step of the payout process to the point that some money actually arrives in the mail for him.

His publisher takes half (the settlement’s default split for trade and university presses). The US taxman takes withholding tax. The lawyers, awarded US$101.6 million in fees for the case, take their cut.

Professor Coiera has kindly offered to shout the first three respondents a coffee with what’s left.

Several colleagues have offered to shout him a beer instead, which seems more apt.

The irony is that it took a piracy case to get him anything. In the US, training on legitimately bought books was ruled fair use. It was the downloads from “shadow libraries” – a pirate website or online archive that hands out copyrighted books and academic papers for free – that cost Anthropic.

Australia’s rules are very different from those in the US, and the argument is a lot louder at the moment.

Attorney-General Michelle Rowland ruled out a text and data mining exception for the US LLMs in October 2025, despite howls of concern from local AI boosters – mostly those invested in data centres.

In July the PM said no company should train AI on Australian work without the artist’s control.

Then leaked slides in September showed an opt-out model under consideration. In October, Anthropic’s envoy Jeff Bleich told a parliamentary inquiry, “You can’t license the entire internet”.

The AFR reports the government now favours rights holders negotiating directly with AI companies, with draft laws for consultation promised by year’s end. The parliamentary committee reports on 30 November.

In a set-up like that, the little people – like Professor Coiera and Health Services Daily – don’t get a deal. We’re a rounding error. The government generally just looks after the people they need on side – like big media and entertainment.

In the last version of this sort of deal the government did a deal with Facebook and Google to help out media organisations. It helped out the big ones – Nine and News Corp. All the small folk were left to fend for themselves.

Meanwhile, the bots keep reading. Claude and ChatGPT both read The Medical Republic and Health Services Daily. The AI that helped draft this column fetched two of our stories while doing it. Ask them about it and, in our experience, they deny it, they argue a bit and then, if you’re persistent, they eventually concede somewhat by suggesting that the law “isn’t settled”.

We don’t even bother trying to block them anymore. There are too many of those autonomous agent buggers to defend yourself. We just think… “oh well, it’s still pretty dumb in the end, and they have no idea what’s just happened and what to make of it…” For now at least.

That’s called “news”.

The law on copyright in Australia is settled of course.

Nothing in our Copyright Act lets anyone copy our journalism to train a model without permission, and the government has said nothing will.

But until someone stands up properly to these monster digital imperialists, the stealing will go on unabated and Professor Coiera’s few coffees are likely to be the going rate of recompense, if you get any.

End of content

No more pages to load

Log In Register ×