Med school curricula fails on sex and gender

6 minute read


But that doesn’t mean Australia’s future doctors aren’t learning about it.


An audit of Australian healthcare degrees has found that only a quarter of medical school curricula mentions sex or gender, and that none mentions sex or gender differences in cardiovascular disease.  

Despite the seemingly poor results, medical students and supervisors said the audit did not tell the full story.  

Undertaken as part of the National Women’s Health Advisory Council work, the 30-page paper looked at every health and medical program accredited by the National Registration and Accreditation Scheme for the extent and nature of sex and gender integration into their curriculum.  

The research team, who were based out of the Centre for Sex & Gender Equity in Health & Medicine at The George Institute, initially expected that approximately 85% of programs would demonstrate “appropriate integration of sex and gender considerations”.  

This was not the case.  

“The finding that 1 in 2 programs contain no mention of sex or gender keywords in any of their curricula, and that only 1 in 10 curricula across all programs mentions sex or gender keywords, reveals that little or no attention has been given to meaningful, evidence-based consideration of how health conditions present differently, disproportionately, or exclusively in people as a function of their sex and gender in Australian health and medical teaching in programs accredited by the National Scheme,” the researchers wrote.  

According to the researchers, this indicated that the male-centric medical model “continues to dominate health and medical teaching and practice”.  

Recommendations included introducing a policy within the National Health and Medical Research Council that all clinical practice guidelines include a standalone section on gender and sex considerations and encouraging the national boards to work with accreditation authorities to integrate sex and gender into curricula. 

But some stakeholders have taken issue with the scope and direction of the audit.  

The students 

Australian Medical Students Association president Seniru Mudannayake told Health Services Daily that the audit “confirms what medical students have been saying for years”.  

“We’re very grateful that it’s cast light on the fact that the status of sex and gender inclusion in medical school at the moment is diabolical,” he said.  

“What I will say is that for a lot of medical students, myself included, our experiences don’t necessarily line up with what that report finds – purely because of the amount of effort that medical students themselves go to in teaching their peers and creating curriculum content that fills these gaps.  

“But it’s incredibly unfair that medical students – particularly women students, gender diverse, trans and intersex students – have had to bear the burden of filling these gaps on their shoulders in an unpaid capacity.” 

Mr Mudannayake said AMSA had created a series of resources to help address the lack of formal education and training on queer health, and that he was aware of peer training groups which existed at different levels of medical training. 

He said he supported the idea of national boards working with accreditation authorities to introduce minimum standards for sex and gender education integration.  

“Accurate sex and gender terminology, accurate information on how sex and gender alter disease presentation and risk factors, equitable visual and clinical representation across teaching materials – these are all things that can be made binding,” the AMSA president said.  

“I think that will have a very tangible effect across accreditation cycles.” 

The supervisors 

GP and training supervisor Professor Louise Stone, whose research looked at why female GPs commonly decided to leave the workforce, told TMR that formal curricula did not necessarily align with what doctors learned in practice.  

“Medicine has a saying that the ‘curriculum’ walks through the door,” she said.  

“Meaning that the patients that we work with and the supervisors that we have, have a large impact on our learning and they aren’t necessarily captured by the formal curriculum. 

“In general practice, for instance, you have 125 hours of face-to-face medical educator teaching, and then you have 125 hours of supervisor teaching, and the supervisors tend to teach what’s in front of the registrars.  

“The registrars will bring problems and issues and concerns to their supervisors to discuss, and that gets as much time as the stuff that follows a formal curriculum.”  

While Professor Stone agreed there was a place for discussion about formalising the integration of gender into health and medical degrees, she was unsure that wording of curricula was the best place to begin.  

“Do the students ever read the curriculum? No, generally not … I’m not seeing that monitoring the curriculum is a fair measure of the degree of sensitivity that occurs in teaching,” she said.  

The medical schools 

Medical Deans Australia and New Zealand executive committee member Professor Michelle Leech, a rheumatologist and head of medicine at Monash University, said the audit had underestimated what was “actually being taught in medical programs”.  

“All medical schools in Australia and New Zealand teach about cognitive bias, including gender bias, and students learn in health care settings from practitioners and, most importantly, from female patients, as part of their extensive clinical placements,” she told HSD.  

“Much of the curriculum regarding gender inequity in health outcomes occurs in areas not deeply examined by the audit; for example, in population health, health knowledge systems, society and health, and evidence-based medicine – rather than in the women’s health, obstetrics and gynaecology, or high-level GP learning outcomes.” 

Professor Leech also said that the medical deans’ association had long advocated for more training opportunities in community and non-acute settings, where the whole patient story “is made visible to the learner”.  

“Medical Deans has, for decades, advocated strongly for expansion of training into non-hospital community settings where students learn about the long-term outcomes, chronic disease burdens, and the whole patient story of women in the Australian health system,” she told TMR.  

“For this reason, the most pressing need for reform at the entry-level stage of medical training is for medical students to have greater access to clinical placements in general practice.  

“This is where most of the continuing and complex health care for women and girls takes place, and it provides a premium clinical learning environment for students.  

“Yet medical schools increasingly struggle to access sufficient clinical placements for their students to learn in these community-based health services.” 

End of content

No more pages to load

Log In Register ×